Ce. Schneider et Jp. Kennett, Segregation and speciation in the Neogene planktonic foraminiferal clade Globoconella, PALEOBIOL, 25(3), 1999, pp. 383-395
The origin of the Neogene planktonic foraminifer Globorotalia (Globoconella
) pliozea in the subtropical southwest Pacific has been attributed to its i
solation resulting from intensification of the Subtropical Divergence (Tasm
an Front). Oxygen isotopic analyses suggest that, although the Subtropical
Divergence may have played a role, the evolution of Gr. (G.) pliozea was fa
cilitated by depth segregation of Gr: (G.) conomiozea morphotypes (low and
high conical) during an interval of near-surface warming and increasing the
rmal gradient. Oxygen isotopic analyses suggest that low conical morphotype
s of Gr. (G.) conomiozea inhabited greater depths than high conical morphot
ypes. Low conical forms of Gr. (G.) conomiozea are considered ancestral to
the low conical species, Gr. (G.) pliozea. Oxygen isotopes indicate that Gr
. (G.) pliozea inhabited greater depths than its ancestor, Gr. (G.) conomio
zea.
These data are consistent with depth-parapatric and depth-allopatric models
, but not with a sympatric model of speciation. In the allopatric model, re
production at different water depths acts as a barrier between morphotypes.
In the parapatric model, clinal variation along a depth gradient acts as a
barrier between morphotypes living at the limits of the gradient. Depth se
gregation in both models results in genetic isolation and evolutionary dive
rgence. Our data support a correlation between morphological evolution and
habitat changes in the Globoconella clade, implying separation of populatio
ns as a driving force for morphological evolution.
Ecological segregation of morphotypes and species map be related to morphol
ogy (height of the conical angle), based on the data from Gr. (G.) conomioz
ea and Gr. (G.) pliozea. However, morphological differences alone do not ne
cessarily produce depth differences. Large morphological differences betwee
n Gr. (G.) pliozea and closely related Gr. (G.) puncticulata did not result
in isotopic and therefore depth differences between these species. These s
pecies coexisted at the same water depths for nearly 1 m.y. Thus, it is unl
ikely that the extinction of Gr. (G.) pliozea in the middle Pliocene result
ed from competition with Gr. (G.) puncticulata, as previously suggested.