The insignificance of null hypothesis significance testing

Authors
Citation
J. Gill, The insignificance of null hypothesis significance testing, POLIT RES Q, 52(3), 1999, pp. 647-674
Citations number
76
Categorie Soggetti
Politucal Science & public Administration
Journal title
POLITICAL RESEARCH QUARTERLY
ISSN journal
10659129 → ACNP
Volume
52
Issue
3
Year of publication
1999
Pages
647 - 674
Database
ISI
SICI code
1065-9129(199909)52:3<647:TIONHS>2.0.ZU;2-V
Abstract
The current method of hypothesis testing in the social sciences is under in tense criticism, yet most political scientists are unaware of the important issues being raised. Criticisms focus on the construction and interpretati on of a procedure that has dominated the reporting of empirical results for over fifty years. There is evidence that null hypothesis significance rest ing as practiced in political science is deeply flawed and widely misunders tood. This is important since most empirical work argues the value of findi ngs through the use of the null hypothesis significance test. In this artic le I review the history of the null hypothesis significance testing paradig m in the social sciences and discuss major problems, some of which are logi cal inconsistencies while others are more interpretive in nature. I suggest alternative techniques to convey effectively the importance of data-analyt ic findings. These recommendations are illustrated with examples using empi rical political science publications.