PARTIAL SUBSTITUTION OF FISH-MEAL AND FULL-FAT SOYA BEAN MEAL WITH WHEAT GLUTEN AND INFLUENCE OF LYSINE SUPPLEMENTATION IN DIETS FOR RAINBOW-TROUT, ONCORHYNCHUS-MYKISS (WALBAUM)
Sj. Davies et al., PARTIAL SUBSTITUTION OF FISH-MEAL AND FULL-FAT SOYA BEAN MEAL WITH WHEAT GLUTEN AND INFLUENCE OF LYSINE SUPPLEMENTATION IN DIETS FOR RAINBOW-TROUT, ONCORHYNCHUS-MYKISS (WALBAUM), Aquaculture research, 28(5), 1997, pp. 317-328
A 65-day study was undertaken to evaluate the utilization of lysine-su
pplemented wheat gluten meal as a protein source for rainbow trout, On
corhynchus mykiss (Walbaum), The performance of the trout fed wheat gl
uten was compared to that of trout where protein was principally suppl
ied using fish meal and full-fat soyabean meal. Six isonitrogenous die
ts (approximately 45% crude protein) were formulated. Thus, the refere
nce diet (FS) was based on fish meal and full-fat soya bean meal while
a further five diets were formulated with a mixture of wheat gluten a
nd wheat middlings used to isonitrogenously replace approximately 75%
and 57% of the full-fat soya and fish meal respectively. Crystalline L
-lysine representing 0.00%, 0.29%, 0.58%, 0.87% and 1.16% of the compl
ete diet was then added to the wheat-gluten-based diets, Optimal perfo
rmance in terms of weight gain and apparent net protein utilization wa
s achieved by the fish fed a wheat-gluten-based diet supplemented with
lysine (0.58%) yielding a digestible lysine level of 1.9% of the comp
lete feed. Within the range of supplements provided, lysine digestibil
ity was high. However, at the highest levels of supplemental lysine th
e relationship between uptake and supplement level was not linear. Add
itionally arginine digestibility was not affected by the level of lysi
ne supplementation. However, amongst the wheat-gluten-based diets, opt
imal performance was associated with a lysine:arginine ratio of 1.1:1.
Despite a lysine:arginine ratio of approximately 1.1:1, the overall p
erformance of the fish fed the fish-meal-soya-based reference diet was
poorer than expected. The results are discussed with respect to optim
al patterns of gross and digestible amino acids, lysine-arginine antag
onism and the possible relationship between antinutritional factors an
d the poor performance of the fish fed the fish-meal-soya-based refere
nce diet.