Fragmentation of brittle materials under high rates of loading is a commonl
y occurring phenomenon, but quantitative descriptions of the process have b
een elusive. Several models for dynamic fragmentation have been suggested i
n the past. In the present paper we consider two such models based on energ
y balance and compare their predictions of fragment size to the results of
numerical simulations. This comparison shows that the energy-balance models
lead to estimates of fragment size which are an order of magnitude larger
than the calculated ones. These differences seem to be due to the fact that
these energy-balance models deal with the onset of the fragmentation event
; they do not include the time dependence of the process. In reality, fragm
entation occurs over finite time during which energy continues to be suppli
ed to the system, and cracks nucleate and propagate throughout the body. Th
erefore, we propose a model that includes the time history of the process a
nd the number, distribution, and strength of flaws in the material. This mo
del is studied by means of both simple analytical methods and computations.
The results provide a consistent picture of fragmentation as a transient e
vent.