In this paper, we compare the structure and the phase behavior of two kinds
of magnetic fluids, also called ferrofluids. They are constituted of the s
ame maghemite particles, the diameters of which lie around 8 nm, dispersed
either in water or in cyclohexane. Both systems are constructed to get the
same interparticle interactions and differ only through the nature of the r
epulsion. Repulsion is either electrostatic, due to the charges of citrate
molecules adsorbed on the particles surface in water, or steric, due to the
alkyl chains of adsorbed surfactants in cyclohexane. Small angle neutron s
cattering (SANS) experiments show that both systems are highly repulsive an
d that the structure factors are very similar. This is confirmed by stabili
ty measurements: the samples are stable if temperature is decreased and if
a magnetic field is applied. If the repulsion is decreased by the addition
of electrolyte in water or bad solvent in cyclohexane, a gas-liquid-like tr
ansition is observed in both systems. However, the standard electrostatic p
otential (Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek potential) fails to describe the
electrostatic repulsion in the aqueous ferrofluid while the behavior of th
is system is very similar to the behavior of the sterically stabilized ferr
ofluid. This underestimate of the electrostatic repulsion is probably due t
o the finite size effects of the trivalent ions. The striking similarities
in the structure and the behavior of both kinds of dispersions, despite the
ir chemical differences, seems to be related to the presence, in both cases
, of the adsorbed surface species which ensure the repulsion between partic
les. Moreover, this repulsion may be described by an effective Yukawa poten
tial very similar in range and intensity in both systems. (C) 1999 American
Institute of Physics. [S0021-9606(99)51336-6].