Ds. Battisti et al., A consistent model for the large-scale steady surface atmospheric circulation in the tropics, J CLIMATE, 12(10), 1999, pp. 2956-2964
The authors present a new model of the tropical surface circulation, forced
by changes in sensible heat and evaporative flux anomalies that are associ
ated with prescribed sea surface temperature anomalies. The model is simila
r to the Lindzen and Nigam (LN) boundary layer model, also driven by the ab
ove flux anomalies; but here, since the boundary layer is assumed well mixe
d and capped by an inversion, the model reduces to a two-layer, reduced-gra
vity system. Furthermore, the rate of exchange of mass across the boundary
layer-free atmosphere interface is dependent on the moisture budget in the
boundary layer. When moist convection is diagnosed to occur, detrainment op
erates on the timescale associated with the life cycle of deep convection,
approximately eight hours. Otherwise, the detrainment is assumed to be asso
ciated with the mixing out of the stable tropical boundary layer, which has
a timescale of about one day. The model provides a diagnostic estimate of
the anomalies in precipitation. However, it is assumed that the latent heat
is released above the boundary layer, and it drives a circulation that doe
s not impact the boundary layer.
The authors discuss the derivations of the Gill-Zebiak (GZ) and Lindzen-Nig
am models and highlight some apparent inconsistencies between their derivat
ion and the values of several of the parameters that are required for these
models to achieve realistic solutions for the circulations. Then, the new
reduced-gravity boundary model equations are rewritten in the form of the G
Z and LN models. Using realistic values for the parameters in the new model
geometry, it is shown that the constants combine in the rewritten equation
s to produce the physically doubtful constants in the GZ and LN models, hen
ce, the reason for the apparent success of these models.