Lr. Churchill, Looking to Hume for justice: On the utility of hume's view of justice for American health care reform, J MED PHIL, 24(4), 1999, pp. 352-364
This essay argues that Hume's theory of justice can be useful in framing a
more persuasive case for universal access in health care. Theories of justi
ce derived from a Rawlsian social contract tradition tend to make the condi
tions for deliberation on justice remote from the lives of most persons, wh
ile religiously-inspired views require superhuman levels of benevolence. By
contrast, Hume's theory derives justice from the prudent reflections of so
cially-encumbered selves. This provides a more accessible moral theory and
a more realistic path to the establishment of universal access.