Among tumors classified as pilocytic astrocytoma (PA) in the Johns Hopkins
Hospital Department of Pathology files, we identified 18 cases with a disti
nctive monomorphous pilomyxoid histological pattern and a higher recurrence
rate than that of PA with classical histological features (classical PA).
The majority of the tumors occurred in infants and young children and invol
ved the hypothalamic/chiasmatic region. The tumors were histologically simi
lar to PA, but they were more monomorphous and more myxoid. Rosenthal fiber
s were not seen and only 1 of 18 tumors had eosinophilic granular bodies. A
t the end of the follow-up period, 6 patients were dead and 12 were alive w
ith evidence of disease. Progression free survival (PFS) at 1 year was 38.7
%. In comparison, we identified a control group of 13 classical PAs in the
same age range and location as the study group. In this group, PFS at 1 yea
r was 69.2%, which was significantly better than that for pilomyxoid tumors
(p = 0.04). There was no CSF dissemination or death due to tumor progressi
on among patients with classical PA. Eight of these patients are alive with
recurrent disease, and 4 have no evidence of disease. While the monomorpho
us pilomyxoid tumors have some resemblance to classical PA, our results sug
gest that the former is a more aggressive variant or a separate entity that
needs to be recognized for prognostic purposes.