Yl. Gu et al., Fundamental properties of the CH center dot center dot center dot O interaction: Is it a true hydrogen bond?, J AM CHEM S, 121(40), 1999, pp. 9411-9422
Ab initio calculations are used to analyze the CH ... O interaction between
FnH3-nCH as proton donor and H2O, CH3OH, and H2CO as acceptor. The interac
tion is quite weak with CH4 as donor but is enhanced by 1 kcal/mol with eac
h F added to the donor. The CH ... O interaction behaves very much like a c
onventional OH ... O H-bond in most respects, including shifts in electron
density that accompany the formation of the bond and the magnitudes of the
various components of the interaction energy. The two sorts of H-bonds also
gravitate toward a similar equilibrium geometry and are comparably sensiti
ve to deformations from that structure. In a quantitative sense, while both
CH ... O and OH ... O prefer a linear configuration, the former is somewha
t more easily bent and is less sensitive to stretches from its equilibrium
H-bond length. Whereas the OH bond has been shown to stretch and undergo a
red shift in its vibrational frequency upon formation of a H-bond, the CH b
ond of the molecules studied here follows the opposite trend, a contraction
and a blue shift. Analysis demonstrates that this opposite pattern is not
due to any fundamental distinction between the two interactions, since the
same sets of forces are acting on both. It is concluded that the CH ... O i
nteraction can, indeed, be categorized as a true H-bond.