W. Wong et al., SYNGENEIC BONE-MARROW EXPRESSING A SINGLE-DONOR CLASS-I MHC MOLECULE PERMITS ACCEPTANCE OF A FULLY ALLOGENEIC CARDIAC ALLOGRAFT, Transplantation, 62(10), 1996, pp. 1462-1468
Bone marrow cells may be a useful vehicle for pretransplant delivery o
f alloantigen to induce tolerance in vivo. However, infusion of fully
allogeneic bone marrow cells carries the risk. of graft-versus-host di
sease. In order to reduce this risk while retaining the tolerogenic po
tential of the bone marrow infusion, we have investigated the ability
of recipient bone marrow cells expressing a single donor MHC class I a
ntigen to induce specific unresponsiveness in vivo. We show that 5 x 1
0(7) and 5 x 10(6) bone marrow cells from a transgenic strain of CBA m
ice, CBK, that express a single donor class I MHC gene, H2K(b) (H2(k)
+ H2K(b)), were able to induce long term survival of a fully allogenei
c C57BL/10 (H2(b)) cardiac allograft in 80% and 20% of unmanipulated C
BA (H2(k)) recipients, respectively, when administered intravenousely
on the day of transplantation. In contrast, the same doses of fully al
logeneic C57BL/10 donor bone marrow were completely ineffective at pro
longing graft survival. When the interval between bone marrow infusion
and transplantation was increased to 14 days, CBK bone marrow at eith
er dose (5 x 10(6) and 5 x 10(7)) induced long term survival of C57BL/
10 cardiac allografts in all recipients (MST>100 days) while fully all
ogeneic donor bone marrow was ineffective (MST=7, 5 x 10(6) cells; MST
=6, 5 x 10(7)). Only when 27 or 42 days had elapsed between bone marro
w infusion and transplantation did fully allogeneic bone marrow exert
a beneficial effect on graft survival. Administration of 5 x 10(6) C57
BL/10 bone marrow cells 27 and 42 days before transplantation resulted
in long term survival of C57BL/10 hearts in 67% and 75% of CBA recipi
ents. Next, we investigated whether manipulating the periphery of the
recipient with a depleting anti-Cd4(4) monoclonal antibody before bone
marrow infusion would facilitate the induction of unresponsiveness. W
hen pretreatment with bone marrow cells was combined with anti-Cd4 mon
oclonal antibody 28 days before transplantation, a 10-fold reduction i
n the number of either C57BL/10 or CBK bone marrow cells required to i
nduce tolerance was observed. These data confirm that bone marrow is a
suitable vehicle for alloantigen delivery at the time of, or before,
transplantation, on its own or in combination with anti-Cd4. The use o
f recipient type bone marrow cells expressing one or more donor MHC ge
nes may be more effective than fully allogeneic, donor bone marrow cel
ls in inducing tolerance in vivo. This difference may have important c
linical implications for the current trials of donor bone marrow given
at the time of transplantation in order to augment chimerism and to p
rolong graft survival.