Pb. Hesseling et al., Neuroblastoma in southern Africa: epidemiological features, prognostic factors and outcome, ANN TROP PA, 19(4), 1999, pp. 357-363
We retrospectively analysed the epidemiological features and the importance
of biochemical, histological and genetic parameters in predicting survival
in 14 Namibian and 34 South African children treated for neuroblastoma (NB
) from 1983 to 1997. Curative treatment consisted mainly of total (13%) or
partial (44%) resection after chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide and doxorubici
n x6 courses or carboplatin, etoposide, epirubicin and cyclophosphamide x6
courses). Localized radiotherapy with curative intent was given to 33% of p
atients. The male:female ratio was 0.9. The median age was 18 months (range
1-116) and was comparable in white, black and mixed ethnic patients. Prima
ry disease was located in the abdomen (75%), thorax (15%), pelvis (5%) or e
lsewhere (5%). Evans stage distribution was: stage I, 2%; stage II, 19%; st
age III, 21%; Stage IV, 50%; and stage IVS, 8%. Stage III/IV disease was mo
re common in black than in white children (p = 0.0001). Urinary vanillyl ma
ndelic acid was elevated in 63% of those tested. Survival after 5-163 month
s' follow-up was 90% for stages I and II combined (median 2983, range 798-4
661 days), 51% for stage III (median 367, range 61-5001 days), 6% for stage
IV (median 227, range 20-4379 days) and 50% for stage IVS (median 532, ran
ge 54-1543 days). All seven children with para-spinal rumours survived. Ind
ividual factors associated with significantly poorer survival were elevated
serum lactate dehydrogenase (p < 0.001), Joshi histological risk categoriz
ation adapted for age (p = 0.039), n-myc amplification (p = 0.006) and dipl
oidy or tetraploidy (p = 0.006). All seven children with serum ferritin exc
eeding 149 ng/ml at the rime of diagnosis died and survival was 33% in chil
dren with Ip deletion and 67% in those without, but the numbers were too sm
all to achieve significance. These findings confirm the benefit of simple b
iochemical tests and histology in identifying those who are likely to respo
nd favourably to conventional chemotherapy and surgery. Supportive genetic
tests on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tumour tissue contributed to pred
icting outcome in 21 patients.