The use of naturally occurring extracellular matrix materials as scaffolds
for the repair and regeneration of tissues is receiving increased attention
. The present study evaluates the use of the extracellular matrix derived f
rom porcine small intestinal submucosa as a scaffold for anterior cruciate
ligament replacement in a goat model, Sixty healthy adult female goats were
divided into two equal groups of 30 each. The right anterior cruciate liga
ment of each goat was removed surgically and replaced with either a patella
r tendon autograft or a small intestinal submucosa anterior cruciate ligame
nt scaffold. Three animals from each group were sacrificed at 6 weeks, 3 mo
nths, 6 months, and 1 year after surgery and grafts were harvested for hist
opathologic examination. Six animals from each group were sacrificed immedi
ately after surgery, 3 months, and 1 year after surgery and the grafts were
harvested for biomechanical testing. There was no evidence for an adverse
clinical response to the xenogeneic small intestinal submucosa scaffold. An
terior drawer values were not different between the two groups at any point
, The failure force of the patellar tendon autograft increased from 253 N a
t Time 0 to 879 N at 12 months. The failure force for the small intestinal
submucosa repair device was 721 N at Time 0, decreased to 293 N at 3 months
, followed by an increase to 706 N at 12 months. Histopathologic analysis s
howed a mixed inflammatory cell presence within the small intestinal submuc
osa scaffold including macrophages and lymphocytes in the early months afte
r surgery. The inflammatory cells disappeared in the later stages of remode
ling and the histologic appearance of the small intestinal submucosa remode
led grafts and the patellar tendon autografts were indistinguishable at 12
months. Xenogeneic small intestinal submucosa holds promise as a resorbable
bio-scaffold for anterior cruciate ligament repair in the goat model.