Video playback has become an important tool for testing certain questions a
bout animal visual perception. While a few studies have compared the respon
se of test subjects to live and video stimuli, it is generally assumed a pr
iori that the animals will respond to the video image as if it were 'real'.
Since video devices are tuned to the spectral sensitivities and flicker fu
sion frequencies of the human eye and brain, it is important to conduct pre
liminary tests to compare the response of test subjects between live and vi
deo images. Here we compare schooling behavior of tiger barbs, Puntius tetr
azona, when presented with a school of live fish, an analog video school of
fish and a video of a computer-animated school of fish. Test subjects did
not show a significantly different schooling behavior response to any of th
ese stimuli. Additionally, when given the choice of schooling with a conspe
cific versus a heterospecific, tiger barbs schooled significantly more ofte
n with the conspecifics for all three stimulus formats. This study provides
evidence that tiger barbs do not choose to discriminate between live and v
ideo models of fish and that this technique can be used to test future ques
tions concerning visual perception for this species.