This research note seeks to offer some resolution to the theoretical disagr
eements over how democratization affects civil society, specifically in a t
ransition toward democracy that occurs through pacted settlements of an arm
ed internal conflict. Using a comparative study over time of the labor move
ment in EI Salvador, the authors demonstrate that while unions of the polit
ical center and left have weakened since the signing of the Salvadoran Peac
e Accords, independent labor groups show higher levels of organizing and ri
ght-leaning unions have maintained nearly constant levels of organizing. Bu
t the labor movement has become atomized because unions have been unable to
redefine their once-common political goals to adopt other unified stances
in the postwar period. The data show that the unions that have relinquished
excessively politicized stances or never claimed them are the ones that su
rvive and sometimes grow in the postwar environment. These findings have im
plications for the nature of the emerging Salvadoran democracy and the econ
omic well-being of its citizens.