Goj. Sjoden et al., 3D-radiographic analysis does not improve the Neer and AO classifications of proximal humeral fractures, ACT ORTH SC, 70(4), 1999, pp. 325-328
Citations number
17
Categorie Soggetti
Ortopedics, Rehabilitation & Sport Medicine","da verificare
The Neer and AO fracture classifications for fractures of the proximal hume
rus have shown poor reproducibility based on plain radiography, We wanted t
o investigate whether the addition of 3-dimensional (3D) reconstructions wo
uld increase the reproducibility of classification. 7 observers independent
ly classified 24 fractures of the proximal humerus using both plain radiogr
aphs, CT and 3D and the classification was repeated 2 months later.
There was a moderate interobserver agreement when using the Neer classifica
tion, but only a fair agreement with the AO classification. The Neer system
had a mean kappa value of 0.44 and the AO had a value of 0.32 for the firs
t assessment. In the second assessment, the mean kappa values were 0.49 and
0.34, respectively. Intraobserver reproducibility was fair to substantial
agreement for Neer (kappa range 0.27-0.73) and for AO (kappa range 0.29-0.7
4).
In conclusion, the addition of CT and 3D to plain radiographs did not impro
ve the reproducibility of the classifications of Neer and AO of the proxima
l humerus.