This paper reviews the history of the establishment of dog breeds, summariz
es current health and resultant welfare problems and makes some positive su
ggestions for their resolution. Some breed standards and selection practice
s run counter to the welfare interests of dogs, to the extent that some bre
eds are characterized by traits that may be difficult to defend on welfare
grounds. Meanwhile, little selection pressure seems to be exerted on some t
raits that would improve animal welfare and produce dogs better suited to U
nfortunately, the incidence of certain inherited defects in some breeds is
unacceptably high, while the number of registered animals of certain breeds
within some countries is so low as to make it almost impossible for breede
rs to avoid mating close relatives. There are several constructive ways to
overcome these challenges. Breed associations can ensure that reduction of
welfare problems is one of their major aims, they can review breed standard
s, they call embrace modern technology for animal identification and pedigr
ee checking; they can allow the introduction of 'new' genetic material into
closed stud-books, and they can encourage collaboration with geneticists i
n identifying and using DNA markers for the control of inherited disorders.
There should be a concerted effort to produce and evaluate as companion an
imals first-cross (F1) hybrids from matings between various pairs of breeds
. Finally, geneticists must learn to communicate their science better and i
n a language that non-geneticists can understand. modern society.