H. Sievanen et al., Disproportionate, age-related bone loss in long bone ends: A structural analysis based on dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry, OSTEOPOR IN, 10(4), 1999, pp. 295-302
The width of long bone diaphyses apparently increase with age, a phenomenon
that is suggested to have some positive impact on bone strength. On the ot
her hand, these changes in size that are site-specific may cause a deterior
ation in the local mechanical integrity of the whole bone. Physical activit
y and calcium intake are known to be able to modify bone mass and size. It
is, however, not known whether these lifestyle habits can modify the postul
ated disproportionate changes in bone size. To address this question, bone
mineral content (BMC)-derived estimates of cross-sectional areas (CSA) of f
emur and radius in 158 premenopausal (mean age 43, standard deviation 2 yea
rs) and 134 postmenopausal (63 (2) years), clinically healthy women with co
ntrasting long-term histories in physical activity and calcium intake were
determined from dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) data. The DXA-obtain
ed BMC correlated strongly with the actual CSA (r = 0.94) determined with p
eripheral quantative computed tomography. The ratios between functionally i
nterrelated CSA data (i.e., (radial shaft CSA/distal radius CSA), (trochant
er CSA/femoral neck CSA), (femoral shaft CSA/trochanter CSA) and (femoral s
haft CSA/femoral neck CSA)) were considered primary outcome variables. Neit
her physical activity nor calcium intake separately or interactively were a
ssociated with any CSA ratio. Age showed no interaction with physical activ
ity or calcium intake but was independently associated with all CSA ratios,
except the ratio of femoral shaft CSA to trochanteric CSA. This study indi
cated clearly that a preferential reduction in the cross-sectional area occ
upied by bone mineral occurs disproportionately at the long bone ends as co
mpared with diaphyseal sites, and this apparently inherent, age-associated
relative loss seems not to be prevented by physical activity or calcium int
ake. In particular, given the utmost clinical relevance of the proximal fem
ur region, an observed loss in femoral neck CSA of about 10% in contrast to
about a 5% loss in trochanteric CSA warrants further investigation regardi
ng its potential role as a predictor for hip fracture. Not only the local d
ifferences in bone composition but also the biomechanical aspects are impor
tant factors underlying these apparent changes in CSA at the studied skelet
al sites.