We analyze the comprehension data in Broca's aphasia, pooled together by Be
rndt, Mitchum, and Haendinges (1996). We show that once analyzed properly,
these data have statistical structure that is very similar to that revealed
by the analysis in Grodzinsky, Pinango, Zurif, and Drai (1999). The sugges
tion that the latter authors doctored the data to obtain a desired outcome
is as false as the claim that the data in Berndt et al. show no regularity.
Comprehension scores in Broca's aphasia do have statistical structure, whi
ch correlates with syntactic structure. Thus, the role of Broca's area and
its vicinity in language processing can be made more precise. (C) 1999 Acad
emic Press.