The effectiveness of calcium carbonate versus calcium acetate and aluminum
hydroxide on improving serum lipid profiles-including serum total, LDL, and
HDL cholesterol and triglyceride levels-was investigated in 68 patients wi
th end-stage renal disease on hemodialysis. Hemodialysis patient volunteers
were divided into two groups: phosphate binder complaint or noncompliant.
Binder therapy compliance was established using the Health Care Financing A
dministration's guidelines. All subjects were further divided based on pres
cribed phosphate binder: calcium carbonate, calcium acetate, or aluminum hy
droxide. Phosphate binder therapies had no significant effects on serum tot
al cholesterol, serum HDL cholesterol, and serum triglyceride concentration
s. However, individuals complying with calcium carbonate binder therapy had
significantly lower serum LDL cholesterol concentrations than compliant su
bjects receiving calcium acetate. Individuals with renal disease on hemodia
lysis are at risk for heart disease. Individuals compliant with calcium car
bonate binder therapy had significantly lower serum LDL cholesterol concent
rations than those compliant with calcium acetate binder therapy.