Echo cancelers commonly employ a doubletalk detector (DTD), which is essent
ial to keep the adaptive filter from diverging in the presence of near-end
speech and other disruptive noise. There have been numerous algorithms to d
etect doubletalk in an acoustic echo canceler (AEC), In those applications,
typically, the threshold is chosen only by some heuristic method and the p
erformance evaluation is very subjective. In this study, we develop a way t
o objectively evaluate DTD algorithms based on the standard statistical met
hods of detection theory. A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) is deri
ved to characterize DTD performance. Several DTD algorithms are examined an
d simulated under typical real-world operating conditions using measured ro
om responses and signals taken from a digital speech database. The DTD meth
ods are then evaluated and compared using the ROC metric.