Jh. O'Keefe et al., Isolated left anterior descending coronary artery disease - Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty versus stenting versus left internal mammary artery bypass grafting, CIRCULATION, 100(19), 1999, pp. 114-118
Citations number
20
Categorie Soggetti
Cardiovascular & Respiratory Systems","Cardiovascular & Hematology Research
Background-Single-vessel coronary artery disease is usually treated with PT
CA, however, this approach when applied to the left anterior descending cor
onary artery (LAD) is hampered by high restenosis rates, often approaching
50%. Coronary stenting (STENT) and left internal mammary artery bypass graf
ting of the LAD (LIMA-LAD) are other options that have been successfully us
ed for single-vessel LAD disease. The optimal mode of revascularization for
patients with isolated single-vessel LAD disease is unclear. The purpose o
f the present study was to examine PTCA versus STENT versus LIMA-LAD with r
espect to short- and intermediate-term outcomes.
Methods and Results-This was an observational retrospective cohort study co
mparing in-hospital and intermediate-term outcomes and functional class amo
ng patients with isolated single-vessel LAD disease revascularization. Cons
ecutive eligible patients were grouped according to their initial revascula
rization procedure and systematically followed up. A total of 704 patients
qualified for the study: 469 in the PTCA group, 137 in the STENT group, and
98 in the LIMB-LAD group. Follow-up data were complete for 97% of patients
and averaged 27+/-13 months. in-hospital mortality for the PTCA, STENT, an
d LIMA-LAD groups was 1.1%, 0%, and 0% (P=0.51), respectively. Median hospi
tal stays after the procedure for the respective treatment groups were 1, 1
, and 5 days (P<0.001), and occurrences of in-hospital myocardial infarctio
n were 0.9%, 1.5%, and 1.0% (P=NS). Repeat revascularization procedures wer
e performed in 30%, 24%, and 5% of the PTCA, STENT, and LIMA-LAD groups (P=
<0.001 for LIMA-LAD versus other groups, P=0.11 for PTCA versus STENT). Act
uarial 2-year mortality was 3.9%, 2.6%, and 1% in the PTCA, STENT, and LIMA
-LAD groups (P=0.33).
Conclusions-Revascularization for isolated LAD disease using PTCA, STENT, o
r LIMA-LAD results in low in-hospital adverse event rates and good long-ter
m results. Repeat procedures are required less often after LIMA-LAD than af
ter either PTCA or STENT. Long-term mortality was not statistically differe
nt, but the trend was for the lowest mortality with LIMA-LAD, a somewhat hi
gher mortality with STENT, and the highest mortality with PTCA.