Ka. Burns et al., Weathering of hydrocarbons in mangrove sediments: testing the effects of using dispersants to treat oil spills, ORG GEOCHEM, 30(10), 1999, pp. 1273-1286
This field study was a combined chemical and biological investigation of th
e relative effects of using dispersants to treat oil spills impacting mangr
ove habitats. The aim of the chemistry was to determine whether dispersant
affected the short- or long-term composition of a medium range crude oil (G
ippsland) stranded in a tropical mangrove environment in Queensland, Austra
lia. Sediment cores from three replicate plots of each treatment (oil only
and oil plus dispersant) were analyzed for total hydrocarbons and for indiv
idual molecular markers (alkanes, aromatics, triterpanes, and steranes). Se
diments were collected at 2 days, then 1, 7, 13 and 22 months post-spill. O
ver this time, oil in the six treated plots decreased exponentially from 36
.6 +/- 16.5 to 1.2 +/- 0.8 mg/g dry wt. There was no statistical difference
in initial oil concentrations, penetration of oil to depth, or in the rate
s of oil dissipation between oiled or dispersed oil plots. At 13 months, al
kanes were >50% degraded, aromatics were similar to 30% degraded based upon
ratios of labile to resistant markers. However, there was no change in the
triterpane or sterane biomarker signatures of the retained oil. This is of
general forensic interest for pollution events. The predominant removal pr
ocesses were evaporation (less than or equal to 27%) and dissolution (great
er than or equal to 56%), with a lag-phase of 1 month before the start of s
ignificant microbial degradation (less than or equal to 7%). The most resis
tant fraction of the oil that remained after 7 months (the higher molecular
weight hydrocarbons) correlated with the initial total organic carbon cont
ent of the soil. Removal rate in the Queensland mangroves was significantly
faster than that observed in the Caribbean and was related to tidal flushi
ng. (C) 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.