In order to classify the hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs) which had diverse
clinicopathologic characteristics, we divided HCCs into two groups accordi
ng to the expression of biliary antigen on the basis of the hypothesis that
the hepatocyte and biliary epithelial cell originate from the same precurs
or cell, and then we investigated the clinical and pathologic characteristi
cs in the two groups. Forty HCC cases with no preoperative treatment and at
least two-year follow-up data were selected among 202 cases of HCC files f
rom 1991 to 1995. Expression of biliary antigen (AE1, cytokeratin 19), p53,
AFP, and Ki-67 in the tumor tissue were assessed by immunohistochemistry.
Positive cytokeratin 19 was noted in one case (2.5%); AE1 was detected in 4
0% of patients; p53 was overexpressed in 20% of patients; and AFP was detec
ted in 45% of patients. No statistical difference between the biliary antig
en positive group (16 cases) and the negative group (24 cases) were noted i
n terms of mean age, sex, presurgical serum AFP level, Child class, and tum
or size. HBsAg positive race was 66.7% for the biliary antigen (-) group an
d 93.8% for the biliary antigen (+) group with a statistically significant
difference (p=0.048). The number of cases for Edmonson-Steiner grade I/II a
nd III/IV were 15 and 9 in the biliary antigen (-) group, and 4 and 12 in t
he biliary antigen (+) group, respectively, with a statistically significan
t difference (p=0.024). The 1, 3 and 5-year disease-free survival races wer
e 69.7, 40.9 and 40.9% for the biliary antigen (-) group and 73.7, 39.1, 39
.1% for the biliary antigen (+) group with no statistically significant dif
ference. The 1, 3 and 5-year overall survival rates were 91.7, 73.8, 66.4%
for the biliary antigen (-) group and 68.8, 34.4, 34.4% for the biliary ant
igen (+) group, with a significantly greater overall survival rate for the
biliary antigen negative group (p=0.045). Poor histopathological differenti
ation, a high HBsAg positive rate and poor overall survival rate were noted
in the biliary antigen positive group and the differences were statistical
ly significant. In conclusion, HCCs with positive biliary antigen, which or
iginates from more primitive cells, is suggested to he more aggressive than
HCCs with negative biliary antigen.