Rd. Murray et al., Influences on quality of life in GH deficient adults and their effect on response to treatment, CLIN ENDOCR, 51(5), 1999, pp. 565-573
OBJECTIVE Studies of the effect of GH on quality of life (QOL) in growth ho
rmone deficient (GHD) adults have reported conflicting results. Recently, h
owever, we have demonstrated that by selecting only those patients with imp
aired QOL the efficacy of GH replacement on QOL can be greatly improved. Th
e improvement in QOL was observed to correlate significantly with that reco
rded before commencing GH therapy. This study aims to assess if demographic
variables affect QOL in untreated GHD adults or the improvement in QOL fol
lowing GH therapy.
DESIGN An open study of GH replacement, initiating treatment with a dose of
0.8 IU/day and titrating the dose by 0.4 IU increments to normalize the IG
F-1 SDS between -2.0 and +2.0 SD of the age related normal range.
PATIENTS 65 severely GHD patients (peak GH < 9 mU/l to provocative testing)
, mean age 38.7 (range 17-72) years. Inclusion criterion was that of subjec
tively poor quality of life on clinical interview.
MEASUREMENTS Blood was taken for insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). The
Psychological General Well-Being Schedule (PGWB) and Adult Growth Hormone D
eficiency Assessment (AGHDA) self-rating questionnaires were used to assess
quality of life at baseline, three and eight months after commencing GH.
RESULTS The patients were subgrouped on the basis of gender, age of onset o
f GHD, pathology and presence of additional pituitary hormone deficits. The
cohort consisted of 40 females and 25 males, 45 of adult-onset (AO) and 20
of childhood-onset (CO). GH deficiency resulted from a hypothalamo-pituita
ry pathology, or treatment thereof, in 36 patients and as a result of crani
al irradiation for a primary brain tumour or prophylaxis in acute lymphobla
stic leukaemia in 29 patients. Isolated GH deficiency (IGHD) was present in
25 patients, and 32 patients were demonstrated to have at least two additi
onal pituitary hormone deficits (MPHD). No significant difference was detec
ted between baseline PGWB scores of the subgroups. Multiple linear regressi
on analysis revealed the age of onset of GHD to be a significant determinan
t of both the baseline PGWB (P=0.05) and AGHDA (P=0.025) scores, AO patient
s perceiving the greater distress. A significant improvement, from baseline
, in both QOL scores was observed in all subgroups at three months, and in
all subgroups at eight months except IGHD, where a trend towards improvemen
t in the AGHDA score was observed but failed to reach significance. The mea
n improvement in the PGWB following GH therapy was not significantly differ
ent between subgroups. Multiple linear regression analysis confirmed baseli
ne PGWB and AGHDA scores to be the most important variable in prediction of
the level of improvement in respective scores following GH therapy. Age of
onset was also observed to be a significant determinant of the PGWB scores
following GH therapy (P=0.02), the CO cohort experiencing the greater impr
ovement. A similar relationship between age of onset and AGHDA scores was n
ot observed (P=0.22).
CONCLUSIONS Baseline QOL as assessed by selfrating questionnaires is influe
nced by the age of onset of the GH deficiency, adult onset patients express
ing the greater distress. Improvements in QOL scores are influenced by both
baseline score and to a lesser extent the age of onset of GHD, the greater
improvement being observed in childhood onset patients. The degree of impr
ovement was observed to be independent of gender, pathology and number of p
ituitary hormone deficits. In a cohort selected by subjectively impaired QO
L, we have demonstrated childhood onset GHD patients perceive themselves to
have less impairment of QOL pretreatment. In contrast to previous data in
unselected cohorts, however, we have shown that those childhood onset GHD p
atients in whom QOL is significantly reduced, show a capacity for improveme
nt that is equal to, if not greater, than that seen in adult onset-GHD pati
ents.