An increasingly popular experimental approach in comparative physiology is
to study the evolution of physiological traits in the laboratory, using mic
robial, invertebrate and vertebrate models. Because selective conditions ar
e well-defined, selected populations can be replicated and unselected contr
ol populations are available for direct comparison, strong conclusions rega
rding the adaptive value of an evolved response can be drawn. These studies
have shown that physiological systems evolve rapidly in the laboratory, bu
t not always as one would expect from comparative studies of different spec
ies. Laboratory environments are often not as simple as one thinks, so that
the evolution of behavioral differences or selection acting on different l
ife stages can lead to unanticipated results. In some cases, unexpected res
ponses to laboratory selection may suggest new insights into physiological
mechanisms, which might not be available using other experimental approache
s. I outline here recent results (including success stories and caveats for
the unwary investigator) and potential directions for selection experiment
s in comparative physiology.