Functional evolution of an arsenic resistance operon has been accompli
shed by DNA shuffling, involving multiple rounds of in vitro recombina
tion and mutation of a pool of related sequences, followed by selectio
n for increased resistance in vivo. Homologous recombination is achiev
ed by random fragmentation of the PCR templates and reassembly by prim
erless PCR. Plasmid-determined arsenate resistance from plasmid pl258
encoded by genes arsR, arsB, and arsC was evolved in Escherichia coli.
Three rounds of shuffling and selection resulted in cells that grew i
n up to 0.5 M arsenate, a 40-fold increase in resistance, Whereas the
native plasmid remained episomal, the evolved operon reproducibly inte
grated into the bacterial chromosome. In the absence of shuffling, no
increase in resistance was observed after four selection cycles, and t
he control plasmid remained episomal. The integrated ars operon had 13
mutations. Ten mutations were located in arsB, encoding the arsenite
membrane pump, resulting in a fourfold to sixfold increase in arsenite
resistance, While arsC, the arsenate reductase gene, contained no mut
ations, its expression level was increased, and the rate of arsenate r
eduction was increased 12-fold. These results show that DNA shuffling
can improve the function of pathways by complex and unexpected mutatio
nal mechanisms that may be activated by point mutation. These mechanis
ms may be difficult to explain and are likely to be overlooked by rati
onal design.