Sa. Jebb et Ms. Moore, Contribution of a sedentary lifestyle and inactivity to the etiology of overweight and obesity: current evidence and research issues, MED SCI SPT, 31(11), 1999, pp. S534-S541
Purpose: The etiology of overweight and obesity is clearly multifactorial,
but ultimately it is determined by the long-term balance between energy int
ake and expenditure. This review will consider the effects on body weight a
nd the risk of obesity of sedentary lifestyles, within the context of dieta
ry habits. Methods: The data from ecological, cross-sectional, and prospect
ive studies that have assessed physical activity and dietary intake and the
ir relationship to body weight were reviewed. Results: Ecological analyses
imply that the increase in the prevalence of obesity is more strongly relat
ed to lower levels of physical activity than higher energy intakes. However
, there is a paucity of pertinent data from cross-sectional or prospective
studies. There is some evidence that both a high proportion of dietary fat
and low levels of physical activity may increase the likelihood of weight g
ain. However, even the most comprehensive studies an unable to account for
more than a small proportion of the interindividual variance in weight gain
, so it is difficult to usefully assess their relative importance. Furtherm
ore, there are insufficient data that pertain to "sedentary lifestyles" to
segregate any putative effect from a protective effect of exercise. All the
data in this review is MHLBI Evidence category C. Conclusions: This review
provides clear evidence that low levels of physical activity are associate
d with an increased risk of weight gain and obesity. On balance, the eviden
ce is suggestive of a causal Link but the experimental designs are too weak
is provide conclusive evidence. The potential effect of interactions betwe
en diet and activity have largely been ignored. To make progress in this ar
ea, a number of key issues need to be resolved with regard to the methodolo
gy, study design, and statistical analysis of prospective epidemiological s
tudies. In the meantime, data need to be drawn from other sources, particul
arly those studies designed to elucidate the mechanism of action of diet an
d physical activity in the etiology of obesity, to establish rational inter
ventions to guide public health policies.