Thirty cases of concurrent Paget's disease and primary hyperparathyroidism: Sex distribution, histomorphometry, and prediction of the skeletal response to parathyroidectomy
Dh. Gutteridge et al., Thirty cases of concurrent Paget's disease and primary hyperparathyroidism: Sex distribution, histomorphometry, and prediction of the skeletal response to parathyroidectomy, CALCIF TIS, 65(6), 1999, pp. 427-435
Studies of the effect of parathyroidectomy (PTX) on bone turnover in patien
ts with the combination of primary hyperparathyroidism (PHPT) and Paget's d
isease (PD) are largely limited to case reports. The etiology of the: combi
nation is disputed. We report 30 patients and their biochemical (n = 17) an
d histomorphometric (n = 4) responses to PTX in 18. All 18 patients except
one had a post-PTX fall in plasma alkaline phosphatase (pAP). There was a s
ignificant positive correlation between the degree of post-PTX fall in pAP
and both the preoperative plasma total corrected calcium (CaC) (P < 0.01) a
nd serum ionized cal cium (P < 0.05). For the patients with CaC levels >3.0
mmol/liter, the mean % fall in pAP was 68% of pretreatment (to 32%). For t
hose with CaC levels greater than or equal to 2.68 mmol/liter the fall in p
AP was >18%. Of 12 literature cases treated by PTX and followed up, 11 had
a postoperative fall in pAP (range 6-83%). Pretreatment bone biopsies (n =
6) could not be distinguished from uncomplicated PD. No significant histomo
rphometric changes were documented postoperatively in the four patients stu
died; however, % fibrotic surfaces declined in each of the four. Of the 18
patients, only one had radiologic subperiosteal erosions preoperatively; no
ne had clinical tetany postoperatively-thus distinguishing this combination
of diseases from severe PHPT bone disease-a situation easily biochemically
confused with this combination. The sex distribution of 2.75:1 F/M in this
series resembles reported ratios in pure PHPT of 2.37:1, unlike the ratios
found in pure PD (0.49-1.01:1). The prevalence of PHPT in PD is 2.2-6.0% (
mean 4.4%) in 1836 patients. In our series, 73% of patients with both disea
ses were females >60 years of age. In population studies >60 years, PHPT wa
s present in 3% of women and 1% of men. Hypercalcemia in PD is frequently a
ttributed to immobilization. As part of this study, we examined 184 patient
s referred with PD for the existence of, and cause of hypercalcemia. Of thi
s group, 21 were hypercalcemic, 19 (90%) of whom had PHPT; none had immobil
ization hypercalcemia. In patients with both disorders, the indications for
PTX should include the potential post-PTX improvement in pagetic biochemis
try and symptoms. The sex distribution (resembling pure PHPT) and the simil
ar prevalence of PHPT in Paget's, and in the elderly population, support th
e likelihood, in most cases, that these two common diseases are associated
by chance.