Two whole genome screens were applied to sibling pairs from the Collaborati
ve Study on the Genetics of Alcoholism (COGA) family data to compare a semi
quantitative method with a standard qualitative approach. The semiquantitat
ive method used a score derived from 11 symptoms, and the qualitative appro
ach used the COGA criteria for alcohol dependence. There was no concordance
in the regions identified by the two models. Three regions of nominal sign
ificance were identified using the symptom score. In these three regions, c
orrelated traits were also analyzed to determine whether linkage could be a
ttributed to their intermediate effect. The evidence for linkage to one loc
us on chromosome 6 could be explained by linkage to the personality trait h
arm avoidance. (C) 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.