We analyzed some simulated data to assess the success of statistical method
ologies to establish the role of the environmental factors (EF) and to iden
tify associated and linked markers. We considered five replicates for each
of the four studies, and, with the knowledge of the generating model, conce
ntrated our analyses on chromosomes (CH) 1, 3, and 5. To determine the infl
uence of EF and associated markers on the affection status (AS), we utilize
d chi-square tests for independence and recursive partitioning (via the CAR
T software). To identify linked markers, we scanned the relevant chromosome
s with nonparametric multipoint linkage (NPL) and transmission/disequilibri
um tests. These analyses were performed on the whole data set as well as on
subsets of individuals and families defined by exposure to EF. CART correc
tly selected the associated marker (D1G024) and EF1 for Study (ST) 1 and di
d not generate trees for the other studies. NPL identified the relevant reg
ions on CH3 and CH5 but failed to do so for CH1, except in ST4. Stratifying
families by exposure to EF1 did not consistently increase sensitivity of N
PL to the relevant CH3 markers, but did help characterize the genetic heter
ogeneity and identify linked families. (C) 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.