F. Parisi, ON THE STRUCTURE FACTOR FOR COMMENSURATE MODULATED STRUCTURES, Acta crystallographica. Section A, Foundations of crystallography, 50, 1994, pp. 574-579
A superstructure may be looked upon as a commensurate modulated struct
ure and be described through the superspace formalism. It can be studi
ed using low- or high-symmetry superspace groups. The possibility of a
dopting a high-symmetry description is related to the existence of at
least two independent three-dimensional sections in the supercrystal w
ith the same space-group symmetry. The usual structure-factor formula
for commensurate structures [Yamamoto (1982). Acta Cryst. A38, 87-92]
includes just one of these sections, thus allowing for a low-symmetry
description only. A very simple generalization of this in the superspa
ce formalism is presented, which allows for the use of either low- or
high-symmetry superspace groups in the structural analysis. The reason
s for a seemingly successful refinement found in the literature, makin
g use of the high-symmetry description, are discussed.