At. Costa et al., Inadequacy of the asymptotic approximation for the interlayer coupling in Fe/Ag/Fe and Fe/Au/Fe (001) trilayers, PHYS REV B, 60(17), 1999, pp. 11894-11897
We discuss the basic assumptions underlying the stationary phase approximat
ion to the interlayer exchange coupling between magnetic materials across n
onmagnetic spacers. We show that, for temperatures and spacer thicknesses o
f interest, it cannot be applied to systems such as Fe/Ag/Fe and Fe/Au/Fe (
001) trilayers. Such inadequacy results from particular confinement effects
caused by the Fe layers in the Ag and Au extremal Fermi-surface "neck" sta
tes. This is of special relevance to the interpretation of experimental dat
a. [S0163-1829(99)04738-4].