OBJECTIVES: Physicians practicing in France are required to participate in
continuing education programs in accordance with the code of deontology and
the offical decree on controlling medical expenditures. We reviewed the li
terature to analyze the efficacy of such training on the way physicians con
duct their practice.
METHODS: We examined the following educational methodologies: diffusion of
educational documents or guidelines, conferences and presentations, interve
ntions by opinion leaders, direct visits at the physician's office. The ana
lysis was based solely on publications issuing from work considered to be v
alid in accordance with the Cochrane collaboration: intervention trials, ch
ronological series, before-after studies with control group.
RESULTS: The diffusion of educational material or more format continuing ed
ucation programs do not appear to have an effect on the way physicians cond
uct their practice, interventions by opinon leaderrs have a demonstrated im
pact but are rarely judged clinically significant Visits to the physician's
office by specially trained health care workers have an effect but this mo
de of education is costly.
CONCLUSIONS: The conventional strategies, such as simple information diffus
ion and continuing education programs, developed to promote an evolution of
clinical practices appear to be the least effective methodologies. (C) 199
9, Masson, Paris.