Purpose Frequency of hip impairment, with sub-luxation or dislocation, duri
ng evolution of neuromuscular diseases depends on intensity and spreading o
f palsy. At the end of growth or at the beginning of adult life, secondary
arthritis can induce pain and lack of mobility. The importance of the chond
ropathy and irreductible lack of congruence may doom to failure a conservat
ive articular or periarticular surgery Total hip arthroplasty is an alterna
tive, but the risks of dislocation, ectopic ossifications and infection mak
e often refute this indication. We report our experience of total arthropla
sty for paralytic hip, about 18 cases.
Materials and methods We reviewed retrospectively 14 consecutive patients w
ith neuromuscular disease, who had 18 total arthroplasties of paralytic hip
s. The origin of neuromuscular disease was cerebral for 7 patients (6 cereb
ral palsy: 4 spastic or athetosic tetraplegies, 1 spastic diplegy, 1 hemipl
egies; 1 head trauma), 6 medullar desorders (1 Friedreich disease, 2 acute
anterior polyomyelitis, 1 vascular injury, 1 malformative spine with sacral
agenesis and 1 cervical spine trauma) and 1 muscular affection (Steinert d
isease). Mean age of the patient was 40 year old (19 to 64). Mean follow up
was 5 years. Intensity and diffusion of weakness were variables, compatibl
es with gait with or without help for 11 patients, and for 3 patients with
sitting posture and transfer. The coxopathy, with pain stiffness and viciou
s attitudes, induced the loss of gait or sitting posture and transfer. The
goal of the arthroplasty was the restitution of the initial function. 11 hi
p had previous surgery, with infection in 2 cases. Arthritis was secondary
to hip palsy in 14 cases (4 dislocations, 6 subdislocations, 3 complication
s of surgery of paralytic hip dislocation in childhood, 1 nervous arthropat
hy), and independant of palsy in 4 cases (1 femoral head avascular necrosis
ans 3 primary arthritis). The prosthesis were LFA Charnley Kerboull in all
cases except 1. We used transtrochanteric approach.
Results Mean follow-up is 5,6 years. Functional initial goal has been obtai
n in all cases. Ectopic ossifications occured in 3 cases, without functiona
l consequence. One acetabular loosening occured after 13 years and has been
reoperated on. There was no polyethylene wear. We noticed 1 mechanical and
2 chemical femoral loosening. Prosthetic dislocation occured in 4 cases, a
lways during the 4 post-operative months, without recurrence after this cri
tical period. There were no infection.
Discussion If gait is possible, there is no satisfactory alternative to tot
al hip arthroplasty. In absence of gait, total hip arthroplasty gives also
the best functional results. Girdlestone procedure is not indicated because
it will induce the loss of transfer and side effects as ascension of proxi
mal femur with recurrence of adduction bringing out pain and sometimes scab
s.
Conclusion Total arthroplasty of paralytic hip induced restitution of initi
al function for all patients and an acceptable rate of complication after s
trict selection of patients and indications, specific operative technique a
nd rehabilitation for each patient. This results encourage us to carry on w
ith this therapeutic orientation.