In this response to Renzulli's 25-year review of his work, I develop 3 ques
tions for examining his perspectives: (a) Does Renzulli's conception reflec
t the gifted population.? (b) Do school system practices reflect the concep
tion? and (c) How do implemented practices of the model affect the school s
ystem and the gifted student I argue that no classroom observational studie
s critically examine the dynamic interaction of Renzulli's Three-Ring Conce
ption of Giftedness, that within a school context it is difficult to operat
ionalize, and that its complexity limits the number of implementation studi
es that focus on its effects. I suggest new questions for research and enco
urage studies that examine closely the database's underlying current practi
ces promulgated in the field of gifted education.