Lf. Degner et al., INFORMATION NEEDS AND DECISIONAL PREFERENCES IN WOMEN WITH BREAST-CANCER, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 277(18), 1997, pp. 1485-1492
Objective.-To determine the degree of involvement women with breast ca
ncer wanted in medical decision making, extent to which they believed
they had achieved their preferred level of involvement, and types of i
nformation they judged to be most important. Design and Setting.-Cross
-sectional survey at 2 tertiary oncology referral clinics and 2 commun
ity hospital oncology clinics in Winnipeg, Manitoba. Patients.-Consecu
tive sample of 1012 women with a confirmed diagnosis of breast cancer
who were scheduled for a visit at 1 of 4 hospital oncology clinics. Ma
in Outcome Measures.-The following measures were used: (1) Preferences
about various levels of participation in treatment decision making; (
2) the extent to which subjects believed they had achieved their prefe
rred levels of involvement in decision making; and (3) priority needs
for information and how these needs differed by selected sociodemograp
hic, disease, and treatment variables.Results.-A total of 22% of women
wanted to select their own cancer treatment, 44% wanted to select the
ir treatment collaboratively with their physicians, and 34% wanted to
delegate this responsibility to their physicians. Only 42% of women be
lieved they had achieved their preferred level of control in decision
making. The 2 most highly ranked types of information were related to
knowing about chances of cure and spread of disease. Women younger tha
n 50 years rated information about physical and sexual attractiveness
as more important than did older women (P<.001); women older than 70 y
ears rated information about self-care as more important than did youn
ger women (P=.002); and women who had a positive family history of bre
ast cancer rated information about family risk as more important than
did other women (P=.03). Conclusions.-The substantial discrepancy betw
een women's preferred and attained levels of involvement in treatment
decision making suggests that systematic approaches to assess and resp
ond to women's desired level of participation in treatment decision ma
king need to be evaluated. Priorities for information identified in th
is study provide an empirical basis to guide communication with women
seeking care for breast cancer.