A prospective nonrandomized study was made of 17 basketball players with fr
actures of the proximal third of the shaft of the fifth metatarsal. Eight h
ad acute fractures, which were treated with a cast without weight-bearing,
and the other nine had stress fractures for which percutaneous compression
screwing was initially used. In the first group, union was obtained in four
cases in an average of 9 weeks, with resumption of sport by 12 weeks. Thre
e had a good outcome and the fourth was fair. The other four cases, which h
ad not healed after 12 weeks of immobilization, were subsequently treated u
sing compression screws. Resumption of sport was achieved 20-24 weeks after
the fracture. Two of these had a good result; in the other two the results
were fair. Of the nine patients with stress fractures in which a screw was
inserted, all healed between 8 and 14 weeks and returned to sport within 7
-12 weeks. Seven had a good result and the other two only fair. There was o
ne intraoperative complication, but no postoperative complications, such as
nonunion or refracture, were observed. Even if the non-operative treatment
is able to provide a good result, immobilization without weight-bearing do
es not guarantee healing. In this series, percutaneous screw fixation was a
ble to achieve successful healing in a short period of time. Thus, this pro
cedure seems to be preferable for primary treatment of this lesion in athle
tes.