Gm. Murphy et al., NO ASSOCIATION BETWEEN APOLIPOPROTEIN-E EPSILON-4 ALLELE AND RATE OF DECLINE IN ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE, The American journal of psychiatry, 154(5), 1997, pp. 603-608
Objective The relationship between number of apolipoprotein E epsilon
4 (APOE epsilon 4) alleles and the rate of cognitive decline in patien
ts with Alzheimer's disease was examined. Method: Rate of decline in s
core on the Mini-Mental State was measured during the active phase of
the decline curve between Mini-Mental State scores of 23 and 0. To cha
racterize onset, the authors also estimated for each subject the age a
t which the Mini-Mental State score fell below 23 and obtained a retro
spective report of age at onset from the caregiver. The number of APOE
epsilon 4 alleles carried by each subject was determined from genomic
DNA samples. The study included 86 subjects with probable Alzheimer's
disease who had had at least two cognitive evaluations (a mean of 5.6
evaluations per subject over an average period of 3.6 years). Results
: The results did not support an association between APOE epsilon 4 do
sage and rate of cognitive decline. Age at onset and age at which the
Mini-Mental State score fell below 23 were also not related to APOE ep
silon 4 dosage. The APOE allele frequencies were similar to those in o
ther studies of subjects with Alzheimer's disease, showing an enrichme
nt of the epsilon 4 allele. Conclusions: Although the APOE epsilon 4 a
llele is a risk factor for Alzheimer's disease, there is no support of
a strong association between APOE epsilon 4 dosage and rate of cognit
ive decline. The epsilon 4 allele did not predict age at onset. Method
ological inconsistencies may account for discrepancies between these r
esults and previous findings.