Lg. Duncan et Rs. Johnston, How does phonological awareness relate to nonword reading skill amongst poor readers?, READ WRIT, 11(5-6), 1999, pp. 405-439
This study examined phonological awareness at the level of phonemes and rhy
me and related this to nonword naming ability. Poor readers were compared w
ith 11 year old chronological-age controls and 8 year old reading-age contr
ols. The poor reader group was impaired for chronological age in all tasks,
and impaired for reading age at nonword naming and phoneme deletion. The p
oor readers' rhyming skills, however, were commensurate with reading age. I
ndividual variation was observed together with exceptions to the group find
ings; most poor readers performed within the range of the reading-age contr
ols on the phonological tasks and in nonword naming. Dissociations in phono
logical skills were evident, including indications that intact awareness of
rhyme may not be a prerequisite for the development of phoneme awareness.
Furthermore, phoneme awareness correlated significantly with poor readers'
word and nonword reading ability, whereas rhyming skill did not. Therefore,
phoneme awareness may be more important than rhyming skill in understandin
g reading disorders.