K. Schonauer et al., Comorbidity of schizophrenia and prelingual deafness: its impact on socialnetwork structures, SOC PSY PSY, 34(10), 1999, pp. 526-532
Background: Prelingually deaf persons usually gain only a rudimentary comma
nd of speech and prefer sign language to communicate within the deaf commun
ity without the handicap they experience in the hearing world. Maintaining
social contact within this rather scattered community, however, requires hi
gher degrees of social initiative and mobility. The aim of the present pape
r was to study the quantity and quality of social integration among a group
of prelingually deaf schizophrenic patients (n = 49) and two control group
s comprising prelingually deaf psychiatric but non-psychotic patients (n =
38) and hearing schizophrenic patients (n = 30), with account being taken o
f the special socialisation conditions of deaf persons and of their cultura
l standards and values, Method: Data were collected with the help of semi-s
tructured interviews; with the deaf patients these were conducted in German
sign language. Using rating procedures we assessed seven social support co
mponents, selected items from a history schedule for schizophrenia, and the
probands' visual and verbal language skills. Results: The social networks
of the two deaf groups were found to have larger gaps than those of the hea
ring schizophrenic patients, with significant differences being registered
most clearly in the comparison between deaf schizophrenic and hearing schiz
ophrenic patients. Comparison of the verbal and visual language skills of t
he two deaf groups revealed a substantial deficit among the deaf schizophre
nics. Visual language skills were found to correlate more strongly than ver
bal language skills with the social support components. Conclusion: Preling
ual deafness has a strong impact on the course of schizophrenia. In the lon
g run, many of these patients belong to a "minority within a minority".