Rd. Bloebaum et al., ANALYSIS OF PARTICLES IN ACETABULAR COMPONENTS FROM PATIENTS WITH OSTEOLYSIS, Clinical orthopaedics and related research, (338), 1997, pp. 109-118
Acetabular polyethylene components were quantitatively analyzed for th
e presence of third body particles from 38 consecutively retrieved com
ponents. Backscattered electron imaging and correlated energy dispersi
ve xray analysis were used for the assessments, Retrievals were divide
d into 4 groups based on methods of fixation and metal alloy types: 8
hydroxyapatite coated, 6 cobalt chrome porous coated, 17 titanium poro
us coated, and 7 cemented implants were evaluated, The backscattered e
lectron imaging data showed that the components from the hydroxyapatit
e coated implants had larger particles than did the components from th
e cemented group, The hydroxyapatite group had 51 +/- 52 particles per
mm(2). The cobalt chrome alloy group had 10 +/- 9 particles per mm(2)
, and the titanium alloy group had 9 +/- 16 particles per mm(2). The c
emented group had 5 +/- 4 particles per mm(2). The difference between
the cement group and the hydroxyapatite group was statistically signif
icant. The elemental analysis showed that 70% of the particles in the
hydroxyapatite group had calcium and phosphorus elements, Third body p
articles likely contribute to particulate generation, The results sugg
est that the hydroxyapatite coated components have the potential for p
roducing greater amounts of particulate debris, Continued analysis of
retrieved components for the presence of the third body particles is r
equired.