The cost of switching between Kanji and Kana while reading Japanese

Citation
M. Shafiullah et S. Monsell, The cost of switching between Kanji and Kana while reading Japanese, LANG COGN P, 14(5-6), 1999, pp. 567-607
Citations number
75
Categorie Soggetti
Psycology
Journal title
LANGUAGE AND COGNITIVE PROCESSES
ISSN journal
01690965 → ACNP
Volume
14
Issue
5-6
Year of publication
1999
Pages
567 - 607
Database
ISI
SICI code
0169-0965(199910/12)14:5-6<567:TCOSBK>2.0.ZU;2-F
Abstract
Readers of Japanese must constantly switch between decoding two types of sc ript, Kana and Kanji. Does this incur a measurable processing cost? In four discrete-trial reaction time experiments, with an inter-trial interval of is or 2s, Japanese readers had to switch predictably, every second trial, b etween reading words in Kanji and Kana (Hiragana in three experiments, Kata kana in the fourth). The task was naming in two experiments, and semantic c ategorisation in two. In every case performance was significantly slower, b y about 13 ms on average, and less accurate, on the trials following a chan ge of script. In these and three further experiments we show that the cost does not arise from changes in spatial extent, number of characters, or the familiarity of words written in the two scripts, that neither the task nor the direction of switching have much impact on the cost, and that there is no cost for switching between naming words in the two Kana scripts, Hiraga na and Katakana, We conclude that to decode Kana and Kanji draws on somewha t different resources, and speculate on the source of the switch cost.