S. Timmermans et M. Berg, STANDARDIZATION IN ACTION - ACHIEVING LOCAL UNIVERSALITY THROUGH MEDICAL PROTOCOLS, Social studies of science, 27(2), 1997, pp. 273-305
Citations number
77
Categorie Soggetti
History & Philosophy of Sciences","History & Philosophy of Sciences","History & Philosophy of Sciences
In this paper, we argue that universality is always 'local universalit
y'. The achievement of local universality depends on how standards man
age the tension involved in transforming work practices, while simulta
neously being grounded in those practices. We investigate how this is
done in two case studies - an oncology protocol and the Cardio Pulmona
ry Resuscitation (CPR) protocol. These protocols are viewed as technos
cientific scripts which crystallize multiple trajectories. In the proc
ess of obtaining local universality, we illustrate how protocols feed
off previous standards and practices. We then indicate how the protoco
ls function through the distributed work of a multitude of heterogeneo
us actors. Finally, we argue that, in this process, the protocols them
selves are necessarily changed and partially reappropriated.