We compare two methods of distance determination to spiral galaxies using o
ptical/near-infrared (NIR) observations, the (I-K) versus M-K colour-absolu
te magnitude (CM) relation and the I- and K-band Tully-Fisher relation (TFR
).
Dust-free colours and NIR absolute magnitudes greatly enhance the usefulnes
s of the NIR CM relation as a distance indicator for moderately to highly i
nclined spiral galaxies in the field (inclinations between similar to 80 de
grees and 90 degrees); by avoiding contamination by dust the scatter in the
CM relation is significantly reduced, compared with similar galaxy samples
published previously. The CM relation can be used to determine distances t
o field spiral galaxies with M-K > -25.5, to at least M-K approximate to -2
0.
Our results, supplemented with previously published observations for which
we can - to some degree - control the effects of extinction, are consistent
with a universal nature of the CM relation for field spiral galaxies.
High-resolution observations made with the Hubble Space Telescope can provi
de a powerful tool to calibrate the relation and extend the useful distance
range by more than a factor of 2 compared with ground-based observations.
The intrinsic scatter in the NIR CM relation in the absolute K-band magnitu
des is similar to 0.5 mag, yielding a lower limit to the accuracy of distan
ce determinations of the order of 25 per cent.
Although we find an unusually low scatter in the TFR (probably a statistica
l accident), a typical scatter in the TFR would yield distances to our samp
le galaxies with uncertainties of only similar to 15 per cent. However, one
of the main advantages of the use of the NIR CM relation is that we need o
nly photometric data to obtain distance estimates; use of the TFR requires
additional kinematic data, although it can be used to significantly greater
distances.