Ak. Sachdeva et al., A new model for recognizing and rewarding the educational accomplishments of surgery faculty, ACAD MED, 74(12), 1999, pp. 1278-1287
Faculty members' educational endeavors have generally not received adequate
recognition. The Association for Surgical Education in 1993 established a
task force to determine the magnitude of this problem and to crate a model
to address the challenges and opportunities identified. To obtain baseline
information, the task force reviewed information from national sources and
the literature on recognizing and rewarding faculty members for educational
accomplishments. The group also developed and mailed to surgery department
s at all U.S. and Canadian medical schools a questionnaire asking about the
educational endeavors of the surgery faculty and their recognition for suc
h activities. The response rate after two mailings was only 56%, but the re
sponses reaffirmed the inadequacy of systems for rewarding and recognizing
surgeon - teachers and surgeon -educators, and confirmed that the distincti
on between the roles of teacher and educator was rarely made. The task forc
e created a four-tier hierarchial model based on the designations teacher,
master teacher, educator, and master educator as a framework to offer appro
priate recognition and rewards to the faculty, and endorsed a broad definit
ion of educational scholarship. Criteria for various levels of achievement,
ways to demonstrate and document educational contributions, appropriate su
pport and recognition,and suggested faculty ranks were defined for these le
vels. The task force recommended that each surgery department have within i
ts faulty ranks a cadre of trained teachers, a few master teachers,and at l
ast one educator. Departments with a major commitment to eduction should co
nsider supporting a master educator to serve as a resource not only for the
department but also for the department's medical school and other medical
schools. Although this model was created for surgery departments, it is gen
eralizable to other disciplines.