Background & Aims: Microsatellite instability in apparently sporadic,
predominantly right-sided colon cancers seems to be the result of an a
cquired, rather than germline, genetic change that impairs mismatch re
pair. The timing of this change with respect to the adenoma-carcinoma
sequence has not been determined. The aim of this study was to evaluat
e colonic adenomatous polyps for microsatellite instability to determi
ne whether instability reflects an early genetic change in colonic neo
plasia. Methods: Ninety-three sporadic colonic adenomas (44 right-side
d and 49 left-sided) from 48 individuals were evaluated for microsatel
lite instability with a set of 10 polymerase chain reaction primer set
s. Results: Eighty percent of adenomatous polyps showed no instability
. Ninety-eight percent showed instability with <30% of primer sets. As
ide from one right-sided adenoma with 78% instability, there was no le
vel of instability with a higher proportion of right-sided than left-s
ided adenomas. Conclusions: Colonic adenomas show far less microsatell
ite instability than carcinomas, and the marked right-sided predominan
ce of instability observed in colon cancers was not observed. Instabil
ity is usually not an early event in the development of colonic neopla
sia. A distinct pathway to sporadic colorectal cancer initiated by mis
match repair deficiency, although not excluded, is not suggested by th
ese data.