O. Brogan et al., LANCEFIELD GROUPING AND SMELL OF CARAMEL FOR PRESUMPTIVE IDENTIFICATION AND ASSESSMENT OF PATHOGENICITY IN THE STREPTOCOCCUS-MILLERI GROUP, Journal of Clinical Pathology, 50(4), 1997, pp. 332-335
Aims-To evaluate Lancefield grouping and caramel smell for presumptive
identification of the Streptococcus milleri group, and to find whethe
r Lancefield group, species, or protein profile correlated with virule
nce or infection site. Methods-Prospective studies were made of 100 co
nsecutive streptococcal isolates in blood cultures or pus from 100 pat
ients in whom the severity of infection was categorised as serious, mo
derate, or not significant. The usefulness of Lancefield group and the
caramel smell for presumptive identification was examined, and the re
lation of the S milleri species, Lancefield group, and SDS-PAGE protei
n analysis to severity of infection and infection site was investigate
d. Lower respiratory tract and genital tract specimens, strict anaerob
es, group D streptococci, and strains identified as Streptococcus pneu
moniae, Streptococcus pyogenes, or Streptococcus agalactiae were exclu
ded. Results-Most streptococci occurring in pure or significant growth
density were S milleri group (87/100; 87%, 95% confidence interval 0.
81-0.93). Of these, 89.7% (78/87; 0.84-0.96) were associated with infe
ction. Lancefield group F antigen predominated (41/87; 47.1%, 0.38-0.5
6). Lancefield group F alone or accompanied by the caramel smell had a
specificity of 100%, but a sensitivity of only 47.3% for group F alon
e, and 19.5% for group F accompanied by the caramel smell. There was n
o significant association between species, Lancefield group, and sever
ity of infection, site of infection, or pathogenicity. SDS-PAGE analys
is failed to discriminate between strains. Conclusions-Neither species
nor Lancefield antigen was related to the site of infection. The pres
ence of Lancefield group F antigen alone or accompanied by a caramel s
mell was a useful indicator for the S milleri group when present, but
was too insensitive to use as a screening test. Most streptococci occu
rring in pure culture or in significant growth density were of clinica
l importance. Such organisms should be identified to species level to
detect the S milleri group.