Propositions and indexicals, a defense of Frege's theory

Authors
Citation
M. Vignolo, Propositions and indexicals, a defense of Frege's theory, LING STILE, 34(3), 1999, pp. 317-338
Citations number
19
Categorie Soggetti
Language & Linguistics
Journal title
LINGUA E STILE
ISSN journal
0024385X → ACNP
Volume
34
Issue
3
Year of publication
1999
Pages
317 - 338
Database
ISI
SICI code
0024-385X(199909)34:3<317:PAIADO>2.0.ZU;2-B
Abstract
In this paper I argue for a defence of the fregean theory of proposition. F rege claims that every proposition is constituted of senses and that the re ferences never enter into a proposition as its parts. I focus on the propos itions which are expressible by uttering sentences containing indexicals. A ccording to the theorists of direct reference, such propositions are singul ar and have the references of the indexicals among their constituents. My a im is twofold: firstly I want to prove that the criticisms directed against the fregean theory are based on premises which are not acceptable from a f regean point of view and also on misleading interpretations of the fregean notion of sense. Secondly, exploiting the McDowell's idea of the "de re sen ses", I present some general suggestions for a reassessment of the fregean notion of "thought".