K. Fiscella et al., BEING A FOREIGNER, I MAY BE PUNISHED IF I MAKE A SMALL MISTAKE - ASSESSING TRANSCULTURAL EXPERIENCES IN CARING FOR PATIENTS, Family practice, 14(2), 1997, pp. 112-116
Background. Emotionally charged issues that arise during graduate medi
cal education often are unrecognized and consequently not addressed by
training programmes. Little attention has been given to the emotional
challenges encountered by international medical graduates (IMG) in ca
ring for patients transculturally. Objectives. We aimed to examine the
value of qualitative approaches to assessing the transcultural experi
ences of IMG residents during primary care training. Methods. Two qual
itative research techniques (the critical incident and the focus group
) were used to assess the transcultural challenges in caring for patie
nts of IMG and American medical graduates (AMG) resident in a primary
care residency programme. Each resident wrote a narrative describing a
challenging experience and facilitators then conducted a focus group
to discuss these experiences. Key themes were identified from the writ
ten narratives and from the transcript of the videotaped focus group.
Results. Previously unacknowledged feelings emerged during the assessm
ent. Themes of struggles for acceptance, fear of rejection, and fear o
f disappointing patients were identified from analysis of the written
narrative, while themes of struggle to express caring transculturally
were identified from the focus group transcript. Based on these findin
gs, significant changes were made to the residency training curriculum
. Conclusions. Qualitative methods are useful for assessing the transc
ultural experiences of IMG residents and for informing curricular chan
ges in residency training. These methods may help other training progr
ammes to identify the particular needs of their trainees in addressing
emotionally laden experiences.