Monitoring agricultural drainage ditches and the receiving water (NicomeklRiver, Surrey, BC) for toxicity to Ceriodaphnia dubia and probable cause due to organophosphate contamination
Mj. Mcleay et Kj. Hall, Monitoring agricultural drainage ditches and the receiving water (NicomeklRiver, Surrey, BC) for toxicity to Ceriodaphnia dubia and probable cause due to organophosphate contamination, WAT QUAL RE, 34(3), 1999, pp. 423-453
The use of organophosphate insecticides on commercial vegetable and blueber
ry farmlands bordering the Nicomekl River, Surrey, B.C., creates the potent
ial for toxic effects on the biota within the drainage ditches and the rive
r itself. To investigate the frequency and magnitude of the toxicity of dra
inage ditch water and the river water in the vicinity of ditch discharge po
ints, together with the probable cause, water samples were collected from s
ix drainage ditches, and four river locations, at 3-week intervals between
June and November 1997. For each of the water samples collected, chronic (7
+/- 1 day) survival and reproduction of the cladoceran test organism Cerio
daphnia dubia were compared to that of Nicomekl River headland waters beyon
d the influence of commercial growing operations. Portions of samples provi
ng to be lethally toxic to the toxicity-test organism were analyzed for org
anophosphate insecticides (OPs) and subjected to treatment with piperonyl b
utoxide to ascertain if OPs were the likely contributing cause of the toxic
ity.
Throughout the 6-month monitoring period, a total of 50 ditch water samples
and 35 Nicomekl river water samples were collected. None of the river wate
r samples tested produced statistically significant mortality. Two (4%) of
the ditch water samples were lethally toxic, with 6- and 7-day median letha
l concentrations (LC50s) of 39.9 and 36.5%, respectively. Seven (14%) of th
e ditch water samples and three (9%) of the river water samples inhibited C
. dubia reproduction. A biological toxicity identification evaluation using
piperonyl butoxide determined that the toxicant(s) in each of the two ditc
h water samples which proved lethal to C. dubia were likely metabolically a
ctive OP insecticide(s). Later chemical analyses on stored portions of the
samples revealed trace quantities of chlorpyrifos and/or diazinon. These an
d other non-measured OPs are believed to have been responsible for the obse
rved lethality. The cause of the inhibited reproduction is for the most par
t unknown. Providing the 1997 growing season is a typical growing season in
terms of OP insecticide use and rainfall, the C, dubia toxicity test resul
ts suggest that during the growing season the Nicomekl River and its draina
ge ditches may periodically be contaminated with OP insecticides at concent
rations high enough to sublethally or lethally impact sensitive ditch and r
iver invertebrate fish-food organisms.